A white wedding turned into more of a wet t-shirt contest when the entire wedding party fell into a lake last week.

According to the Daily Dot, the unlucky couple were a pair of newlyweds named Dan and Jackie Anderson who tried to take a Pinterest-worthy wedding party photo on a not-so-sturdy pier. Although it seems at least one bridesmaid escaped her watery fate, the rest of the party plunged into the lake.

On the bright side, at least the damp toast-givers had a topical theme to joke about afterwards—Did you two ever guess your marriage would be literally sink or swim? Dan, are you crying, or is that just lake water?—or, hopefully, not.

[h/t Daily Dot]