Despite agreeing to discuss a specific set of topics beforehand, Washington Examiner columnist Tim Carney attempted to derail a conversation about Mitt Romney's response to his "youthful indiscretion" by calling NewsNation host Tamron Hall's question a "typical media trick."

Hall has none of it, and, after calling Carney out on his double-dealing, promptly cuts off his mic and moves on.

Some feel Hall made MSNBC look bad by "pulling a Bill O'Reilly," while others think Hall was right to shut Carney down for his underhanded attempt at using the platform he was given in order to criticize her.

Judge for yourself.